What Is the SAVE America Act and How Does It Mandate Voter ID?

The SAVE America Act, recently passed by the US House of Representatives, mandates proof-of-citizenship for voter registration ahead of the midterm elections. This legislation requires individuals to present either a valid US passport or a birth certificate, sparking concerns about potential voter disenfranchisement, particularly among those who have changed their names. While proponents argue it is essential for preventing voter fraud, critics claim it may obstruct eligible voters from participating in elections.

Last updated: 25 October 2023 (BST)

What’s happening now

The SAVE America Act has successfully passed through the House with a narrow 218-213 vote, primarily along party lines. This legislation aims to tighten the voter registration process by requiring proof of citizenship and valid photo identification. Proponents, including many in the Republican Party, assert that these measures are necessary to secure election integrity. However, the bill's future in the Senate appears uncertain, as it lacks sufficient support for passage.

Key takeaways

The SAVE America Act mandates proof of citizenship for voter registration.
Concerns are raised about potential disenfranchisement, especially for those who have changed their names.
The legislation passed the House but faces significant hurdles in the Senate.

Timeline: how we got here

The journey of the SAVE America Act includes several key milestones:

2020: Allegations of widespread voter fraud emerge following the presidential election.
October 2022: A previous version of the SAVE America Act is introduced but fails to pass.
October 2023: The House passes the current iteration of the SAVE America Act with a 218-213 vote.

What’s new vs what’s known

New today/this week

The latest version of the SAVE America Act introduces stricter requirements for proving US citizenship and includes provisions for those who have undergone name changes, which has become a point of contention among various advocacy groups.

What was already established

Federal law already requires voters in national elections to be US citizens, but it does not mandate proof of citizenship at the time of registration. The SAVE America Act aims to close this gap.

Impact for the UK

Consumers and households

While the impact of this legislation is primarily felt in the US, it raises questions about voting rights and access to democratic processes, which may resonate with UK citizens, especially in discussions about voter ID laws and election integrity.

Businesses and jobs

For businesses in the US, the act could create additional compliance burdens, particularly for those involved in the electoral process. However, the direct impact on UK businesses is minimal, as the legislation pertains to US citizens.

Policy and regulation

This bill reflects ongoing debates regarding voter ID laws in both the US and the UK. As the UK grapples with its own election-related regulations, the SAVE America Act may influence discussions on similar policies across the Atlantic.

Numbers that matter

21 million Americans lack documents proving their citizenship readily available.
2.6 million Americans do not possess any form of government-issued photo ID.
83% of respondents in a Pew Research Center poll supported requiring photo identification for voting.
71% of Democratic-leaning voters and 95% of Republican-leaning voters favoured photo ID requirements.

Definitions and jargon buster

Proof-of-Citizenship: Documentation required to establish an individual's status as a citizen of the United States.
Voter ID Laws: Regulations that require individuals to present specific identification to vote.
Filibuster: A procedural tactic used in the Senate to delay or block legislative action.

How to think about the next steps

Near term (0–4 weeks)

The immediate focus will likely be on the Senate's response to the House's approval of the SAVE America Act and whether it will schedule a vote on the measure.

Medium term (1–6 months)

If the bill does progress, the next several months will involve discussions and potential modifications to address concerns raised by various stakeholder groups, particularly around disenfranchisement.

Signals to watch

The scheduling of a Senate vote on the SAVE America Act.
Any amendments proposed or changes to the bill that may arise during Senate discussions.
Public opinion shifts regarding voter ID laws as the midterm elections approach.

Practical guidance

Do

Stay informed about changes in voting laws that may affect your ability to register or vote.
Ensure you have the necessary documentation ready if you need to prove your citizenship.

Don’t

Don’t ignore the potential impact of voter ID laws on your community.
Don’t assume that existing voter registration documents are sufficient without verifying them against new requirements.

Checklist

Verify your voter registration status.
Gather necessary documents like a passport or birth certificate.
Stay updated on any legislative changes regarding voting rights.
Engage with local advocacy groups to understand the implications of new laws.

Risks, caveats, and uncertainties

As the SAVE America Act moves forward, there are significant uncertainties regarding its acceptance in the Senate. The lack of bipartisan support and the potential for increased voter disenfranchisement raise concerns about the bill's implications. Additionally, the ongoing narrative around electoral fraud, despite the absence of evidence, may further complicate discussions surrounding this legislation.

Bottom line

The SAVE America Act represents a contentious shift in US voting laws, aimed at tightening voter registration processes through proof-of-citizenship requirements. As the bill faces challenges in the Senate, its implications for voter access and electoral integrity remain a critical topic of discussion, potentially influencing similar debates in the UK context.

FAQs