Can a Mother's Battle for Justice Inspire a TV Drama?

This article recounts the poignant story of Ann Ming, whose relentless quest for justice following the murder of her daughter, Julie Hogg, has inspired a new ITV drama series. Julie was killed by William 'Billy' Dunlop in 1989, and despite his initial acquittal, Ann's fight led to significant changes in UK law regarding double jeopardy. The drama, titled *I Fought the Law*, explores this heart-wrenching journey and the emotional impact on Ann and her family.

Last updated: 31 August 2023 (BST)

Key Takeaways

• Julie Hogg was murdered in 1989 by William 'Billy' Dunlop, who initially escaped justice.
• Ann Ming campaigned to reform the double jeopardy law, allowing retrials in cases with new evidence.
• The ITV drama *I Fought the Law* depicts Ann Ming's 17-year struggle for justice.
• Sheridan Smith portrays Ann Ming, highlighting the emotional depth of the story.
• The double jeopardy law was amended in 2005, leading to Dunlop's retrial and sentencing.

The Tragic Story of Julie Hogg

In 1989, 22-year-old Julie Hogg was found murdered in her home in Billingham, County Durham. Her life was tragically cut short by William 'Billy' Dunlop, a domestic abuser who would later boast about the crime while incarcerated for other offences. Despite being charged with her murder, Dunlop was acquitted after two juries failed to reach a verdict, leaving Julie's family in a state of anguish and injustice.

Ann Ming's Fight for Justice

Julie’s mother, Ann Ming, was not willing to let her daughter’s death go unanswered. Her determination to seek justice transformed into a campaign against the double jeopardy law, which at the time protected those acquitted of a crime from being tried again, even if new evidence emerged. Ann’s battle lasted for 17 arduous years, during which she faced numerous setbacks but remained resolute in her quest for justice.

The Campaign for Change

Ann's fight was not just personal; it resonated with many in the UK who felt that the law was outdated and unjust, especially in cases involving serious crimes. She worked tirelessly, gathering support from legal experts, victims' rights advocates, and the public to push for a change in legislation.

The Double Jeopardy Law

The double jeopardy law, which dates back over 800 years, was designed to protect individuals from being tried for the same crime more than once. However, Ann Ming’s experiences highlighted significant flaws in this system. In 2005, after extensive campaigning, the law was amended, allowing retrials in certain circumstances where new evidence or confessions emerge. This pivotal change meant that offenders like Dunlop could be held accountable for their actions, even after an initial acquittal.

Retrial and Sentencing of Dunlop

In 2006, following the amendment of the law, William Dunlop was retried for the murder of Julie Hogg. The new evidence, including his confession to a prison officer, ultimately led to his conviction. He was sentenced to life in prison, finally bringing some closure to Ann Ming and the Hogg family.

The ITV Drama: *I Fought the Law*

ITV’s four-part series *I Fought the Law* dramatizes Ann Ming's extraordinary journey. Starring Sheridan Smith as Ann, the series captures the emotional weight of her fight and the profound impact of Julie's murder on their family. Ann described the experience of watching the series as deeply emotional, stating that it brought back memories of her struggle and the pain of losing her daughter.

Sheridan Smith's Portrayal of Ann Ming

Sheridan Smith, known for her roles in various popular British series, expressed her honour in portraying Ann Ming. She immersed herself in research, reading Ann's book, *For the Love of Julie*, and studying every available article on the case. Smith's dedication to authentically representing Ann's experience has been praised, as she sought to convey the emotional truth of the story to viewers.

The Impact of Ann Ming's Story

Ann Ming's campaign and the subsequent changes to the law not only impacted her family's life but also set a precedent for future cases. By sharing her story through the drama, Ann hopes to raise awareness about the broader issues surrounding justice and the legal system in the UK. She aims to inspire others who may feel powerless in the face of injustice, proving that systemic change is possible.

Legacy of Julie Hogg

Though Julie Hogg's life was tragically cut short, her story continues to resonate and inspire change. Ann Ming believes that her daughter would be proud of the fight she undertook on her behalf. As she reflected on the drama and her journey, she stated, "I believe that when I die, she'll be waiting for me there. I think she'll be pleased that I did what I did."

Conclusion

The story of Ann Ming and her daughter Julie Hogg is a powerful reminder of the resilience of the human spirit in the face of overwhelming grief and injustice. The ITV drama *I Fought the Law* not only immortalises their story but also serves as a testament to the possibility of change within the legal system. As viewers engage with this narrative, it will undoubtedly spark conversations about justice, reform, and the importance of fighting for what is right.

FAQs

What happened to Julie Hogg?

Julie Hogg was murdered by William 'Billy' Dunlop in 1989. Despite his initial acquittal, he was later retried and convicted after Ann Ming campaigned for changes to the double jeopardy law.

What is the double jeopardy law?

The double jeopardy law prevents a person from being tried for the same crime more than once, even if new evidence emerges. This law was amended in 2005 to allow for retrials in specific circumstances.

Who is Ann Ming?

Ann Ming is the mother of Julie Hogg, who fought tirelessly for justice after her daughter’s murder. Her campaign led to significant changes in UK law regarding double jeopardy.

When will *I Fought the Law* air?

The ITV drama *I Fought the Law*, which depicts Ann Ming's fight for justice, premiered on 31 August 2023.

How did Sheridan Smith prepare for her role as Ann Ming?

Sheridan Smith prepared for her role by researching extensively, reading Ann Ming's book and studying articles about the case to authentically portray her journey and emotional experience.