Should Israel Be Banned from International Sports? Spanish PM Weighs In

Spain's Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez has called for Israel's exclusion from international sports competitions due to its actions in Gaza, likening the situation to Russia's invasion of Ukraine. His comments have sparked significant controversy, drawing responses from Israeli officials and prompting widespread public protests in Spain.

Last updated: 26 October 2023 (BST)

Key Takeaways

• Pedro Sánchez demands Israel's exclusion from international sports events, citing its actions in Gaza.
• His remarks drew condemnation from Israeli officials, who labelled him a "disgrace."
• Public protests in Spain have mobilised tens of thousands against Israel's actions, reflecting widespread sentiment.
• European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen calls for a suspension of trade and support with Israel.
• A significant portion of the Spanish population believes genocide is occurring in Gaza.

Background on the Gaza Conflict

The ongoing conflict in Gaza, which escalated significantly following the Hamas-led attack on Israel on 7 October 2023, has led to severe humanitarian crises. The Israeli military response has resulted in a staggering death toll, with over 64,000 reported fatalities in Gaza as per the Hamas-run health ministry. Civilian casualties and destruction have raised international alarm and calls for accountability.

Sánchez's Call for Action

Prime Minister Sánchez's recent statements mark a significant shift in Spain's foreign policy towards Israel. During a meeting with representatives of his Socialist Workers' Party, he affirmed that "Israel cannot continue to use any international platform to whitewash its image." This declaration aligns with a growing sentiment among many in Spain and beyond, urging a reevaluation of relations with Israel based on its actions in Gaza.

Comparisons to Russia

Sánchez's comparison of Israel to Russia, following its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022, underscores the severity with which he views Israel's military operations. By suggesting that Israel should face similar consequences, Sánchez seeks to highlight the implications of military aggression on civilians and the need for international accountability.

Response from Israeli Officials

In response to Sánchez's comments, Israeli Foreign Minister Gideon Saar described the Spanish Prime Minister as "a disgrace." He accused Sánchez of inciting protests against Israel, which culminated in the cancellation of the final stage of the Vuelta a España cycling race, where an Israeli team was scheduled to compete. The fallout from Sánchez's statements illustrates the deepening diplomatic rift between Spain and Israel.

Public Sentiment in Spain

The Spanish public's reaction to the Gaza situation has been overwhelmingly supportive of pro-Palestinian movements. A recent poll by the Elcano Royal Institute revealed that approximately 82% of Spaniards believe that genocide is being committed in Gaza. This widespread belief is reflected in the mass protests that have taken place across Spain, with demonstrators calling for action against what they perceive as ongoing atrocities.

Government Officials Weigh In

Several Spanish ministers have echoed Sánchez's sentiments. Óscar López, the Minister of Digital Transformation, stated, "It's a relief to me that thousands and thousands of people mobilise against that genocide, because it is genocide and it has no other name." Such declarations from government officials contribute to the growing narrative within Spain that seeks to hold Israel accountable for its actions.

Impact on International Competitions

In addition to calls for Israel's exclusion from sports competitions, Culture Minister Ernest Urtasun has reiterated Sánchez's earlier demands regarding Israel's participation in the Eurovision Song Contest. This move is part of a broader strategy to isolate Israel diplomatically and socially due to its actions in Gaza. Urtasun stated, "We have to make sure that Israel does not take part in the next Eurovision," reflecting a commitment to use cultural platforms as avenues for political statements.

International Reactions

The reactions to Sánchez's statements are not confined to Spain. European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen has also called for a suspension of free trade and bilateral support with Israel, citing the "man-made famine" in Gaza. This growing chorus of condemnation suggests a shift in how European leaders are addressing the humanitarian crisis and the actions of the Israeli government.

Israel's Defence and International Aid Concerns

Israel has consistently denied accusations of genocide and maintains that its military actions are a necessary means of self-defence against Hamas. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has publicly asserted that where there is hunger in Gaza, it is the fault of aid agencies and Hamas, rather than Israeli actions.

However, reports from international organisations, including the UN, have indicated that famine conditions exist in parts of Gaza. The ongoing blockade and restrictions imposed by Israel on food and medical supplies have contributed to this dire situation, raising questions about Israel's responsibilities as an occupying power under international law.

The Humanitarian Crisis in Gaza

The humanitarian crisis in Gaza has escalated to alarming levels. As Israel controls all border crossings into the territory, the flow of essential supplies has been severely restricted. Reports indicate that hundreds of aid trucks are stationary at the borders, unable to deliver crucial support to those in need. The UN-backed food monitor, IPC, has confirmed the existence of famine in several areas of Gaza, exacerbating the already dire humanitarian situation.

Responsibility under International Law

Under international law, Israel, as the occupying power, bears the responsibility for protecting civilian life, which includes preventing starvation. This legal obligation has come under scrutiny as the situation continues to deteriorate, prompting calls for greater accountability from the international community.

Future Implications

The ongoing conflict and the international response to it could have far-reaching implications for diplomatic relations within Europe and beyond. Sánchez's calls for action against Israel, alongside the rising public sentiment in Spain and other European nations, may lead to a reevaluation of how countries engage with Israel moving forward.

With the situation in Gaza rapidly evolving, it remains to be seen how international bodies, including the European Union, will respond to these calls for accountability and what measures may be implemented in the near future.

FAQs

What did Pedro Sánchez say about Israel's actions in Gaza?

Pedro Sánchez called for Israel's exclusion from international sports competitions, stating that Israel cannot use such platforms to "whitewash its image," likening its actions to those of Russia in Ukraine.

How has Israel responded to Sánchez's comments?

Israel's Foreign Minister Gideon Saar labelled Sánchez a "disgrace" and accused him of inciting anti-Israel protests in Spain, which led to the cancellation of a cycling event featuring an Israeli team.

What is the public sentiment in Spain regarding the Gaza conflict?

A significant majority of Spaniards, approximately 82%, believe that genocide is occurring in Gaza, as indicated by a recent poll. This sentiment has spurred large-scale protests against Israel's actions.

What actions have European leaders taken regarding Israel?

European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen has called for a suspension of free trade and support with Israel, citing the humanitarian crisis in Gaza. This reflects a growing call for accountability among European leaders.

What is the humanitarian situation in Gaza?

The humanitarian situation in Gaza is dire, with reports of famine conditions and severe restrictions on aid. The UN has confirmed that famine exists in parts of Gaza, exacerbated by Israel's blockade and military actions.

As the global community continues to react to the unfolding events in Gaza, the implications for international relations and humanitarian efforts remain critical. How will these developments shape future dialogues about accountability and human rights on a global scale? #GazaCrisis #InternationalRelations #HumanRights