Did Marcus Freeman Ignore a Simple Solution? Ex-Notre Dame QB Calls Out Costly Decision!

Notre Dame's defence is currently under intense scrutiny following a disappointing 0-2 start to the 2025 season, raising serious questions about Marcus Freeman's decision to appoint Chris Ash as the defensive play-caller. Once known for their physicality and disciplined coverage, the Irish defence has faltered, highlighted by key mistakes and ineffective performances that have left fans and analysts frustrated.

Last updated: 15 October 2023 (BST)

Key Takeaways

• Notre Dame's defence is struggling after an 0-2 start, raising concerns about coaching decisions.
• Chris Ash's play-calling has come under fire, especially after a critical missed holding call against Texas A&M.
• Marcus Freeman remains focused on improvement despite the team's setbacks and criticism.
• Former defensive coordinator Mike Mickens is being suggested as a better fit for the role.
• The Irish's performance against Texas A&M was marked by a lack of pressure and poor execution.

The State of Notre Dame's Defence

After two games, the Notre Dame Fighting Irish find themselves grappling with a crisis of confidence on defence. Under the guidance of Chris Ash, who was appointed to replace former defensive coordinator Mike Mickens, the team has struggled to maintain the high standards set in previous seasons. The Irish defence, which was once a formidable unit, has been outplayed and outsmarted, leading to a wave of disappointment and frustration among fans and analysts alike.

Initial Expectations vs. Reality

At the start of the season, hopes were high that Ash could revitalise the struggling defence. However, the reality has been starkly different. The defence has failed to adapt to Ash's new system, resulting in missed assignments and a lack of cohesion on the field. The palpable frustration is compounded by the team's inability to generate pressure on opposing quarterbacks and contain their ground game.

Critical Moments Highlighting Defensive Failures

The turning point in the season thus far came during the game against Texas A&M, where a missed holding call on the Aggies' offensive lineman Chase Bisontis directly led to a game-winning touchdown. This blunder, described by officiating expert Terry McAulay as a "patently egregious missed offensive holding foul," has put Ash's play-calling and defensive strategies under a microscope. Such mistakes not only impact the game but also fuel the narrative that the defence is unravelling under pressure.

Performance Breakdown: Texas A&M Game

Against Texas A&M, the Irish defence allowed a staggering 488 rushing yards, averaging 7.1 yards per play. The Aggies, despite committing 13 penalties for 86 yards, managed to dominate the field, showcasing the Irish defence's inability to respond effectively. The lack of sacks and quarterback pressure was particularly concerning, as it rendered the defence virtually ineffective. In contrast, Texas A&M's offensive strategies exploited the Irish's weaknesses, leaving them scrambling to keep up.

Mixed Signals from the Coaching Staff

Amidst the turmoil, Coach Marcus Freeman has remained steadfast, insisting on finding ways to improve the team's performance. “I can’t sit here and dwell on being 0-2 as much as I need to dwell on how we find ways to improve,” he stated after the game. His commitment to evaluating the team's strategies and working on execution is commendable, but it raises questions about the coaching decisions leading to this point.

Former Players Weigh In on Coaching Choices

Former Irish quarterback Malik Zaire has been vocal about his discontent regarding the current defensive situation. He openly suggested that Mike Mickens, who previously held the position of defensive coordinator, should have been retained instead of bringing in Ash. Zaire's comments reflect a growing sentiment among fans that perhaps a more experienced leader could have prevented the current struggles. His criticism underscores the pressure on Freeman to make the right calls moving forward.

Looking Ahead: What Needs to Change?

As the 2025 season progresses, the Irish defence must undergo significant changes to regain its former glory. Here are several key areas that require immediate attention:

• Improved Communication: The players must communicate more effectively on the field to avoid missed assignments and blown coverages.
• Enhanced Pressure on Quarterbacks: Finding ways to generate pressure will be crucial in thwarting opposing offences.
• Discipline in Coverage: The defence needs to maintain disciplined coverage to limit big plays and keep opponents at bay.
• Adaptability: The coaching staff must be willing to adjust their game plan based on the strengths and weaknesses of both their players and the opposition.

What Happens Next?

The coming weeks will be critical for Notre Dame as they navigate through a tough schedule. With each passing game, the pressure on Freeman and Ash intensifies. The question remains: can they turn the tide and restore faith in the Irish defence? The team must rally together, focusing on improvement and cohesion to avoid further disappointment.

Conclusion

As it stands, Notre Dame's defence is at a crossroads. With a strong emphasis on improvement and accountability, the coaching staff must take decisive action to rectify the current issues. The Irish faithful are hoping for a turnaround, but it requires not just strategic adjustments but also a collective effort from both coaches and players. As the season unfolds, one can only wonder if Notre Dame can reclaim its defensive prowess or if further changes are needed to steer the programme back on course.

FAQs

What is the main issue with Notre Dame's defence this season?

The primary concern is the lack of execution and cohesion under the new play-calling of Chris Ash, leading to significant lapses and missed opportunities.

Who is Chris Ash and why was he hired as defensive coordinator?

Chris Ash is a former defensive coach with experience in collegiate football. He was hired to revitalise Notre Dame's defence but has faced criticism for his strategies and play-calling.

What did Malik Zaire say about the defensive situation?

Malik Zaire expressed frustration over the decision to hire Chris Ash instead of retaining Mike Mickens, suggesting that Mickens would have been a better fit for the role.

How can Notre Dame improve its defence moving forward?

Improvements can be made through better communication, generating more pressure on opposing quarterbacks, and maintaining disciplined coverage during games.

What is Marcus Freeman's stance on the team's current performance?

Marcus Freeman acknowledges the team's struggles but remains focused on finding solutions and improving the team's overall performance.

As the Irish navigate this challenging season, fans are left wondering whether their beloved team can find a way to turn things around. The stakes are high, and every game counts. #NotreDame #CollegeFootball #DefensiveChallenges