Will Berthoumieu's 12-Match Ban Keep Him Out of the Semi-Finals?

In a significant development during the Rugby World Cup, French back row Axelle Berthoumieu has received a 12-match ban for biting Ireland's Aoife Wafer in a quarter-final match. This disciplinary action will keep Berthoumieu sidelined for crucial fixtures, including the semi-final against England and potentially the final, as well as a number of domestic matches. The incident occurred during a tense match where Berthoumieu has accepted the red-card offence but plans to appeal the severity of her suspension.

Last updated: 27 September 2023 (BST)

Key Takeaways

• Axelle Berthoumieu has been banned for 12 matches for biting Aoife Wafer.
• The ban excludes her from the semi-final against England and possibly the final.
• Manae Feleu also faces a ban for a high tackle, with a potential reduction for completing a tackle school.
• Both players intend to appeal their bans in front of a disciplinary committee.
• The incident was not penalised during the match, as the TMO saw no clear foul play.

The Incident: A Closer Look

The biting incident involving Axelle Berthoumieu occurred during the second half of the quarter-final match against Ireland, which ended with a score of 18-13 in favour of France. The moment unfolded when Ireland secured a penalty turnover, and in a heated exchange, Berthoumieu allegedly bit Wafer. This action led to immediate scrutiny after the match, as Ireland's captain, Sam Monaghan, brought the matter to the attention of the referee, Aimee Barrett-Theron.

Despite Monaghan's report, no immediate action was taken during the match, which has raised questions about the effectiveness of the officiating. The Independent Foul Play Review Committee (FPRC) later examined the footage from various angles and concluded that Berthoumieu had indeed committed a foul play, resulting in the substantial ban.

The Consequences for France

Berthoumieu's suspension not only impacts her participation in the upcoming matches but also significantly affects the French squad's strategic planning leading into the semi-finals. She was a key player, and her absence will force the coaching staff to adjust their game plan against a formidable England side.

Manae Feleu's Situation

In addition to Berthoumieu's ban, France's co-captain Manae Feleu has also been cited for a high tackle during the same match. Initially facing a three-match suspension, Feleu's penalty could be reduced to two matches if she completes a tackle school, a programme aimed at improving player safety and tackling technique. Feleu has also decided to appeal her ban, suggesting that the French team is determined to contest the decisions made against them.

The Disciplinary Hearing

The appeals for both players will be reviewed by a disciplinary committee on Tuesday. This hearing will examine the evidence presented, including video footage and written statements, to determine whether the bans will be upheld or modified. The outcome of this hearing will be crucial for France as they prepare for their semi-final clash against England.

Implications for the Rugby World Cup

Berthoumieu's biting incident has raised broader discussions about player conduct and the enforcement of rules within the sport. Incidents of foul play, especially those involving biting or serious injuries, are taken very seriously and can lead to significant penalties. The situation also highlights the role of match officials and the TMO in ensuring player safety and maintaining the integrity of the game.

With the Rugby World Cup nearing its climax, the stakes are high for all teams involved. Each match not only represents a chance for glory but also the potential for reputational damage in the wake of disciplinary actions. The disciplinary committee's decisions will set precedents for how similar incidents are handled in the future.

What Happens Next?

As the semi-finals approach, France must pivot and adapt to the absence of key players like Berthoumieu and potentially Feleu. The team will need to rely on its depth and resilience to face England, a formidable opponent with a strong track record in the tournament.

For Berthoumieu and Feleu, the immediate future involves navigating the appeals process and hoping for a favourable outcome. The disciplinary committee's ruling will shape their careers moving forward, particularly in a competitive international landscape.

As rugby fans await the outcome of the appeals and the ensuing matches, the focus remains on the players' conduct and the ongoing evolution of rugby regulations concerning player safety.

FAQs

What was the incident involving Axelle Berthoumieu?

Axelle Berthoumieu was cited for biting Ireland's Aoife Wafer during a Rugby World Cup quarter-final match, leading to a 12-match ban after the Independent Foul Play Review Committee reviewed the evidence.

How long is Axelle Berthoumieu's ban?

Berthoumieu has been banned for 12 matches, which includes the semi-final against England and ten domestic matches through to March 2026.

Can Berthoumieu appeal her ban?

Yes, Berthoumieu has accepted that she committed an offence but plans to appeal the length of her suspension.

What is the situation with Manae Feleu?

Manae Feleu has received a three-match ban for a high tackle, which could be reduced to two matches if she completes a tackle school. She is also appealing the decision.

How does this incident affect the French rugby team?

The bans imposed on key players like Berthoumieu and Feleu will require the French team to adjust their strategies as they prepare to face England in the semi-finals of the Rugby World Cup.