Are Tesla's Faulty Door Handles Endangering Kids? Investigation Launched!

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) has launched an investigation into potential defects affecting the electronic door handles of the 2021 Tesla Model Y. Reports indicate that these issues may have resulted in children becoming trapped inside the vehicle, necessitating dangerous measures such as breaking windows to rescue them.

Last updated: 28 October 2023 (BST)

Key Takeaways

• NHTSA opens a preliminary investigation into 2021 Tesla Model Y door handle defects.
• Reports indicate children have been trapped due to malfunctioning electronic door handles.
• Manual door releases are present but may be inaccessible to children.
• Investigation covers approximately 174,300 vehicles.
• Concerns arise over the reliability of power supplies to electronic door locks.

The Investigation's Background

The NHTSA's investigation stems from multiple reports indicating that the electronic door handles of the 2021 Tesla Model Y may fail to operate under certain conditions, particularly when the vehicle's battery voltage is low. In several alarming incidents, parents have reportedly had to resort to breaking windows to free their children trapped inside.

These troubling reports have raised significant safety concerns, particularly regarding the accessibility of manual releases. While Tesla has installed manual door releases, NHTSA has highlighted that a child may not be able to reach or effectively operate these mechanisms in an emergency. This situation has led to four documented cases where parents felt compelled to break windows to access their children.

Previous Issues with Tesla Door Functionality

This latest investigation is not an isolated incident. Tesla has faced scrutiny in the past regarding the operational reliability of its door mechanisms. There have been numerous reports of drivers being trapped in their vehicles due to malfunctioning doors, especially in critical situations such as accidents. For instance, a recent incident involved a college athlete whose Tesla Cybertruck caught fire after a crash, leaving him unable to escape through the doors.

Additionally, a lawsuit was filed last year by the family of a Tesla Model 3 driver, who tragically lost their life due to being trapped in a burning vehicle. The lawsuit alleges negligence and fraud against Tesla, claiming that the company failed to rectify a design flaw despite numerous incidents of fires involving its cars. This case currently awaits resolution in the Los Angeles Superior Court.

Scope of the NHTSA Investigation

The NHTSA's investigation will focus primarily on the operability of the electronic door locks from outside the vehicle. Notably, the agency will not investigate the manual operations of the doors from the inside, as these can still be opened manually. However, the NHTSA has expressed its commitment to monitor instances of "entrapment" where individuals are unable to exit the vehicle, indicating that further actions may be taken based on the findings.

Approximately 174,300 Tesla Model Y vehicles are included in this preliminary investigation. Reports suggest that these issues typically arise when the electronic locks fail to receive sufficient voltage from the vehicle's battery. Interestingly, records indicate that, in many cases, customers did not receive a low-voltage battery warning prior to the malfunctioning of the door handles, leading to questions about the reliability of the power supply systems.

What Happens Next?

The NHTSA's investigation will assess the scope and severity of the reported door handle issues. It will also evaluate how Tesla supplies power to the door locks and the overall reliability of these systems. This scrutiny comes at a time when Tesla is facing various challenges, including ongoing investigations into other safety features, such as its "summon" technology which allows cars to navigate to drivers autonomously.

In addition, NHTSA opened a probe last year into the driver-assistance features of 2.4 million Teslas due to several accidents occurring in low-visibility conditions, which included a fatal incident involving a pedestrian. Another investigation was initiated in August regarding Tesla's reporting practices to the NHTSA, focusing on the timely reporting of crashes as mandated by regulations.

The Broader Implications for Tesla

As Tesla continues to innovate in the electric vehicle sector, the pressure is mounting on the company to demonstrate that advancements in its driver-assistance technologies are not only effective but also safe. CEO Elon Musk has ambitious plans to roll out hundreds of thousands of self-driving vehicles and Tesla robotaxis by the end of next year. However, this goal must be balanced with ensuring that existing safety issues are adequately addressed.

Recent sales figures have indicated a decline in Tesla's market performance, raising concerns about the company's ability to maintain its reputation as a leader in the electric vehicle industry. Musk's controversial political statements and support for certain policies may also be alienating some of Tesla's environmentally-conscious customer base, further complicating the company’s public image.

Conclusion: Safety First

As the NHTSA's investigation unfolds, it is crucial for Tesla to prioritise the safety of its customers, particularly vulnerable passengers like children. The findings from this investigation may have significant implications not only for Tesla's operational practices but also for consumer trust in the brand. With the ongoing scrutiny from regulatory bodies, the automotive industry is reminded of the importance of safety and reliability in vehicular design.

How will Tesla respond to these safety challenges, and what changes might be implemented to ensure the safety of all passengers in the future? #TeslaSafety #NHTSA #ElectricVehicles

FAQs

What specific defects are being investigated in the Tesla Model Y?

The NHTSA is investigating potential defects related to the electronic door handles of the 2021 Tesla Model Y, which may fail to operate correctly, leading to entrapment of passengers.

How many vehicles are affected by this investigation?

Approximately 174,300 Tesla Model Y vehicles are included in the preliminary investigation by the NHTSA.

What steps has Tesla taken to address door malfunction issues?

Tesla has installed manual door releases inside the vehicles; however, concerns remain about their accessibility for children in emergency situations.

Has Tesla faced similar issues before?

Yes, Tesla has previously been scrutinised for issues with door functionality, including incidents where drivers were trapped in burning vehicles due to malfunctioning doors.

What is the significance of this investigation for Tesla?

This investigation may impact Tesla's reputation and sales, as consumer trust hinges on the reliability and safety of its vehicles.