Is St. John's-MSG Partnership Breaking New Ground?

In recent seasons, the St. John’s Red Storm basketball team has experienced a revival, culminating in significant achievements and increased attendance. This article delves into the complexities surrounding the decision to move a pivotal game to Madison Square Garden (MSG), the implications of this choice, and what it means for both the team and their loyal fanbase.

Last updated: 27 October 2023 (BST)

Key Takeaways

• St. John's sought to clinch its first Big East regular-season title since 1985.
• Moving the game to MSG raised concerns among the university and athletic department.
• Secondary market ticket prices soared, indicating high demand.
• The rivalry with Seton Hall added significance to the home game.
• Decisions like this reflect broader trends in college sports

Background of St. John’s Basketball

St. John’s University, based in Queens, New York, has a storied basketball programme that has seen its share of ups and downs. Historically significant in the Big East Conference, the Red Storm has had moments of brilliance, including NCAA tournament appearances and conference championships. However, the team has struggled in recent years, making the quest for a Big East title particularly poignant.

The Importance of the Big East Regular Season Title

Winning the Big East regular-season title holds immense importance for St. John’s. It represents not just a trophy but a return to prominence in a competitive conference that includes prestigious teams. The last time St. John’s claimed an outright title was in the 1984-85 season, a historical benchmark that this year's team aimed to surpass.

The Decision to Move the Game

The decision to shift the final home game against Seton Hall from Carnesecca Arena to Madison Square Garden was fraught with uncertainty. While the allure of MSG, known as the "Mecca of Basketball," is undeniable, it also comes with risks. Athletic Director Ed Kull reflected on the hesitations faced by both the university and the Garden, noting concerns about the move's potential impact on attendance, revenue, and team morale.

Reasons for Hesitation

Several factors contributed to the reluctance to relocate the game:

• Historical Performance: Previous games at MSG had variable attendance, and there was no guarantee that St. John's would fill the larger venue.
• Financial Risks: Event costs and potential losses loomed large, particularly if ticket sales did not meet expectations.
• Fan Engagement: Moving a game can disrupt the connection fans have with their home venue, impacting the atmosphere.

Rising Demand and Secondary Market Prices

As anticipation built for the game, ticket prices on the secondary market surged. This surge signified strong demand, with many fans eager to witness the rivalry against Seton Hall. The excitement surrounding the potential title clinch only heightened this fervour, leading to discussions about the economic implications of hosting the game at MSG versus Carnesecca Arena.

Understanding the Rivalry with Seton Hall

The rivalry between St. John's and Seton Hall is one of the most storied in college basketball. Both teams have passionate fanbases, and games between them are often characterised by intense competition and high stakes. This historical context added layers of significance to the decision to move the game, as it was not just about the title but also about bragging rights and local pride.

What Happens Next?

With the decision made, the focus shifts to the implications of hosting the game at MSG. If St. John's succeeds in clinching the title, it could lead to a resurgence in interest and support for the programme. Conversely, a poor turnout or a loss could dampen enthusiasm and raise questions about future venue choices.

The Broader Context of College Basketball

St. John's decision reflects broader trends in college basketball, where programmes grapple with balancing tradition and modernisation. The move to larger venues is becoming increasingly common as teams seek to maximise revenue and fan engagement. However, the shift can also alienate core supporters who prefer the intimacy of smaller arenas.

Conclusion

The decision to move St. John's final home game to Madison Square Garden carries with it the weight of history and the expectations of a passionate fanbase. As the team aims for a significant victory against Seton Hall, all eyes will be on the outcome and what it means for the future of the programme. Will this be a turning point for St. John's basketball? Only time will tell.

FAQs

Why did St. John’s move the game to Madison Square Garden?

St. John’s moved the game to Madison Square Garden to capitalise on the larger venue's potential for higher attendance and revenue, especially with the chance to clinch a title.

What are the implications of winning the Big East title for St. John’s?

Winning the Big East title would signify a return to prominence for St. John’s, potentially attracting more recruits, increasing fan engagement, and enhancing the programme's reputation.

How does the rivalry with Seton Hall affect this game?

The rivalry adds emotional weight to the game, as both teams have competitive histories, making the stakes higher for players and fans alike.

What risks were associated with moving the game?

Risks included potential financial losses if ticket sales fell short, disruption of fan engagement, and the uncertainty of filling a larger venue.

What are the benefits of playing at MSG?

Benefits include greater visibility, the prestige of the venue, and the potential for higher ticket sales due to increased demand for significant games.